POST: For our first post for the summer, I would like for you to think about and write roughly 200 words about your best/and or worst experiences as a student in a classroom. You can post about one or the other (best or worst) or you can post about both. Besides telling each other about the experience, try to put into words what made is a great experience or such a bad one. You can write about any kind of student experience, doesn't have to be an ELA experience, though it can be, and you can write from any class you've been a student in from K-12 through college. I will start us off with my own story.
RESPOND: Once you've posted, read through your classmates posts. In roughly 100 words, try to respond to what you see here in terms of what the experiences have in common? What seems to make a good classroom experience good across all of our collective experiences? What seems to make a bad experience bad? I'll read through these posts and put together some summative comments together as part of an upcoming Class Update. HOW TO POST TO POST: when you are ready to post your two questions, simply click on the "comments" button in the top right or bottom left of this screen. A dialogue box will pop up. Enter the identification information (your name, email) and then enter your 300 words in comment section. Click "submit" and you are done. TO REPLY: Simply click the "reply" button at the bottom of any post or scroll all the way down to the last post to the "Leave a Reply" section. Fill out the dialogue boxes like you did for posting and click "submit."
26 Comments
LT
5/26/2020 03:15:23 pm
I hate to start this post with a downer, but I think the singular most influential teaching/learning experience I had a student happened for me in first grade.
Reply
Hannah Dziadyk
5/26/2020 03:49:20 pm
One of my best experiences in my schooling career came in my freshman year of high school. I decided to take a foreign language for the first time. Most student take a course in middle school but I was enrolled in another class to help my math skills. Anyways, I was very interested in Italian which was offered at my school and wanted to take on this challenge. And oh boy was this a challenge, I was struggling a lot in the class and I was doing well in every other class with an A and I was at a C- in Italian. My teacher Mrs Demello could see I was struggling and she knew I was very busy after school with my sports so she offered to come in early in the morning before school to help me. I wanted to get an A in the class to make honor roll but I wasnt thrilled about getting up even earlier because I went to bed super late, because by the time my sport was over and I had dinner it was late. But Mrs Demello believed in me and was willing to do the extra work with me to catch me up to speed so I could get that A that I wanted. In the end you just need one teacher/professor to believe in you can help you succeed. I am thankful for her and I went on to take Italian all four years and my senior year I went to Italy on a school trip!
Reply
Ali Nolan
5/26/2020 06:09:56 pm
Hi Hannah,
Reply
Kylie Bock
5/29/2020 09:27:01 am
Hi Hannah,
Reply
Ali Nolan
5/26/2020 06:00:42 pm
One of the worst experiences I've had, that still subconsciously effects me to this day was in first or second grade. My teacher absolutely hated me, and I did the best I could to please her. It never worked out. She trashed me and my parents for the way I would dress. I tried to submit projects and would fail them because I had help from my mom. No matter what I did she could not stand me. It got to the point where she would find ways to get me in trouble. I was almost kicked out for hugging people. She filed a complaint that hugging was inappropriate. Because of this, I always thought I was a broken or bad child. No, I never was. I was (and still am) deeply creative and caring about people. I suppose what I've taken from that experience is that you can't please everyone, but that's okay! To turn this into a positive, I know what not to do. I know how it feels to be picked on, singled out for a bias. My students will never feel that way in my classroom. Everyone will have an equal opportunity to achieve something, no matter how they get there (so long as they're not cheating). I've worked a lot on myself and the way I view others through my job working at a daycare. Every student, no matter the age, deserves to feel wanted and heard in a classroom.
Reply
Megan LeBlanc
5/26/2020 08:34:40 pm
Hi Ali,
Reply
Hannah Dziadyk
5/27/2020 09:19:31 am
Hi Ali!
Reply
Lindsay Vo
5/27/2020 02:09:00 pm
Hi Ali,
Reply
Megan LeBlanc
5/26/2020 08:27:43 pm
Sorry this is a bit long, but this situation gets me incredibly angry even all these years later. One of my worst years of schooling (and probably my most influential as a student) was sometime in middle school (for whatever reason I cannot remember the exact year – I want to say it was sixth though) and it was only because of one teacher that I had. He was our history teacher and he was incredibly mean. He made fun of most of his students and tried to play it off as though he was being friendly and only joked with you if you were okay with it – the problem with this, however, was that he would joke with basically everyone until they directly told him to stop. One day, he was making fun of me and a boy that I liked. I decided to make some rude comment in retaliation because I was so upset. He pulled me aside after class to tell me to never disrespect him in front of his class again and that if I did not want to be joked with anymore, I wouldn’t have to be. I remember this so clearly because I was completely humiliated and felt so small. I remember thinking I had done something wrong. It wasn’t until later in my life that I realized the teacher was actually the one in the wrong. It took even longer for me to truly realize how wrong it was for a teacher to treat a group of middle schoolers the way that he did. One of my only main goals that I intend to keep with every single group of students I have over the years is to ensure that I treat my students like a person who deserves respect, not a plaything that I can embarrass just because I want to.
Reply
Lydia Theriault
5/27/2020 06:24:40 am
Hi Megan!
Reply
Maddie Butkus
5/28/2020 01:26:35 pm
Hey Megan!
Reply
Lydia Theriault
5/27/2020 06:15:27 am
I have had both bad and good experiences in school that have impacted me equally. I will share a happy experience though!
Reply
Brianna Walsh
5/27/2020 03:48:50 pm
Hi Lydia!
Reply
Matt Erti
5/28/2020 12:42:30 pm
Hi Lydia!
Reply
Fiona Bell
5/27/2020 08:19:18 am
My best class experience stems directly from the teacher I had during it. It was a photography class that I got to take my junior and senior year in high school and I walked into it knowing little to nothing about photography itself. My teacher, however, was adamant in making sure that everybody knew there was no perfect way to take pictures, let alone do anything in life. It was all about how we interpreted it, how hard we tried, and how passionate we were about the things we were doing. His students walked into the classroom comfortable and confident that they wouldn’t be singled out for making simple mistakes or made to feel inferior for not doing things The Right Way. I’d say every class of his was my “best class experience” because he wove life lessons into the photography lessons he’d teach, and emphasized over and over again that we were in control of our life- that we were the ones who could mold it into everything we wanted it to be. That we were capable. And not many teachers I’d had before, or even had since, have been able to truly get that message across. What made it the Best was the fact that we knew he believed in us, that he was always there to help us if we needed him and that he had effortlessly changed the stereotypical relationship between teachers and their students.
Reply
Lindsay Vo
5/27/2020 01:41:39 pm
Like all of you, I've had some positive and negative experiences when it comes to teachers and professors. Out of all the teachers I've had though, one sticks out the most. When I was in high school, I had a teacher named Mr. Damelio and he was there for me when no one else was. My senior year of high school was the worst year of them all: I didn't have many friends and I was constantly getting picked on. In the mornings, we had to stay in the cafeteria until the bell rang, but every morning I would sneak into his classroom and talk to him. I could talk to him about anything: how I was feeling, how I was doing in school, you name it. I would also eat lunch in his classroom since I had no one to sit with at lunch. I felt completely alone, and if it wasn't for Mr. Damelio, I don't know where I would be. He wasn't your average teacher, either: he always made things fun. For example, he created a game called "Poobah" and it's basically like basketball. Everyone loved it, and it was very fun. He will never know the impact he has made on my life, but it was the only thing I looked forward to as a high school senior.
Reply
Brianna Walsh
5/27/2020 02:33:55 pm
One of my best experiences would have to be in 7th grade with Mrs. Stone. She was a new special education teacher and was very outgoing. I was shy and just got into the special education program. I originally felt like an outsider and hated reading because I had so much trouble with it. I was always the person who was afraid to get called on. Those feelings completely changed after a year with this teacher. I learned that I was supported in that classroom and that I wasn’t an outsider. She would start off by asking who would want to read this paragraph for the class. She took off the pressure by not calling on us to read. Eventually I did volunteer to read, and I was nervous that all eyes would be glaring at me to hurry up, but there wasn’t. She would be supportive and tell us how good we are doing. She made it such a positive environment to the point where I wasn’t shy anymore and loved raising my hand. There was only three people in that class. She would designate 30 minutes to read a book of our choice and encourage us to read at home too. She always pushed us to reach our goals and strengthened our weaknesses. She created a safe environment by showing she respects us, supports us, and wants us all to succeed. Even to this date I have gone to visit her, and she lights up with a smile on her face asking how I am. She is by far the best special education teacher I have had.
Reply
Kaylee Tavares
5/28/2020 11:28:13 am
Hi there,
Reply
Paige Couture
5/27/2020 05:19:12 pm
This experience is hard to write about—I will tell this story in hopes it will help others and provide a healthier environment. I have had a tough student teaching experience while pursuing my associate degree. I am thankful for this experience because it turned me into a better educator. I am not the only one who has had a difficult time with this teacher. My student practicum allowed me to practice as a Lead Teacher, being supervised by the real teacher of the classroom. I did not have a lot of experience teaching. Now that I look back, I believe I did have enough to pass the class. The other teacher in the classroom and I did not agree with the way we did certain things. If I did not do something a certain way, the way she had, I would have been talked to by my college professor about the experience. For example, if I held the book I was reading in a certain position (where the students could still see the book), was not acceptable to her. I would get marked down, if I did not say certain lines during circle time in the same words that she had spoken. There were times where I was passing out lunch to children. If I had put a spoonful of a vegetable on the plate, that would be considered as too much for children. She did not know what I was thinking. During lunch break, I was using my phone and there was another student from my class next to me using hers, too. The real teacher told my professor I was using my phone while teaching. I felt like if I breathed a certain way, I would be talked to about irregular breathing patterns around the children. It was to the point where I had gotten the position as Lead Teacher taken and I was brought down to a regular teacher. This was said in a meeting in front of the real teacher, which upset me even more. I tried to tell my professor that we were not agreeing about certain things, but she did not believe me. I could have dropped the class. I decided to “suck it up” and stay, to stick up for myself. Someone in my last practicum, who had gone to this facility, could not take it anymore. Continuing, I took everything the real teacher had said about me to heart. I do not regret this because I do not make the same mistakes today. The story ends by having to re-take the college course at another daycare. I hope this story teaches other students to have a healthier work environment.
Reply
Alexa Parham
5/27/2020 07:59:59 pm
Hi Paige,
Reply
Alexa Parham
5/27/2020 08:31:48 pm
So, this experience was bad and good -
Reply
Paige Couture
5/28/2020 10:10:46 am
Hi Alexa,
Reply
Kaylee Tavares
5/28/2020 09:19:17 am
One of my worst experiences while in school was with my 8th grade algebra teacher. Now, to be fair, I was pretty much destined to hate this class. First of all, I am horrendous at math and have always hated every math class I’ve had to take. But also, it was 8th grade, and pretty much everything in life made me miserable at that point in my life. However, I must note that this teacher was particularly difficult. He was an older man ready to retire, and actually only worked half days. He would teach my class and one other and then leave for the day. He had this horrific system in which he would read test and quiz grades aloud to the class, as he thought it was motivating to the students. Of course, I almost never got a decent grade on an assessment, and thus was humiliated everytime he decided to read them aloud, which was probably once a week. As an insecure, hormone-ridden, miserable middle-schooler in the midst of puberty, to say I was unhappy would be an understatement. However, this was particularly troubling for me because it genuinely made me hate going to school, and I’ve always loved school. I decided I wanted to be a teacher in Kindergarten because I couldn’t imagine a better place than school. That sentiment has never waivered with exception to that one 8th grade class. It’s difficult to accept that one teacher can change a student’s entire outlook on school. I can’t imagine how that teacher would have affected a student who already disliked school.
Reply
Maddie Butkus
5/28/2020 12:02:04 pm
I have had a lot of great experiences but for this post I am going to focus on one of my worst just because I feel like it made me realize how not to be as a teacher. This story still occurs to me even to this day which will make more sense to everyone by the end. So I was in first grade and I had a teacher who obviously was not in love with her job. She not only was very sarcastic to her students but also to the parents as well. Not to speak negatively but to say the simple truth, she acted as if she was all that and a bag of chips, as the saying goes. Even with this as her apparent mindset, she went as far as to make students almost feel dumb for saying the wrong answer. At least, that’s how I remember it. Her discipline styles within the classroom were straight up yelling and making students feel bad for a simple mistake. Since she was extremely into Nascar, she had all the students names written on cars surrounding a test track and when you did something she didn’t like, your “car” was put in different levels of the track ultimately ending in the pit. Just that phrase alone I thought to be so demeaning. She would say “Uh oh so-and-so is in the pit.” I don’t know exactly but that doesn’t seem entirely right to me. Looking back at it now, I get what she was trying to do with this discipline strategy but overall I don’t believe it registered with her students that well. To get back to my point of how this story still occurs to me today, when I see this teacher, whether it was through middle school, going back to this school to help classes during high school or anything in between, she tries to act nice but in general is still very sarcastic. I have stood up to her more, especially because the last time I saw her was just a year ago or so, but it bothers me so much that I even have to do that: stand up for myself because of a long lasting affect a teacher had on me. It just comes to show me first hand how I do not want to be as a teacher at any level that I teach. I don’t want to put my students down for their mistakes or be negatively sarcastic to them in any way.
Reply
Matt Erti
5/28/2020 12:34:12 pm
Hello everyone!
Reply
Kylie Bock
5/29/2020 09:21:25 am
I'd have to say that my worst experience in school was in the fourth grade. My primary teacher was Mrs. Carrier but she split teaching subjects with another teacher down the hall Mrs. Martin. I loved learning math and science with Mrs. Carrier because she was gentle, kind, and made a lot of Harry Potter references. However, english and history with Mrs. Martin was my least favorite part of the day. She was rude, harsh, and quite literally seemed like she did not like children. I was a very anxious child and being around Mrs. Martin made me nervous so I would constantly play or twirl with my hair to get my mind off it. She was walking around the class making sure everyone was reading and I was reading while twirling my hair. She came next to me a slapped my hand down then continued walking. Her behavior and attitude made me resent english for many years until I got to high school.
Reply
Leave a Reply. |