TORDA'S FALL 2025 TEACHING SITE
  • Home
  • ENGL 489 Advanced Portfolio
    • ENGL 489 SYLLABUS >
      • GUIDELINES FOR BEING PRESENT ONLINE
    • ENGL 489 AUTHOR BIOS >
      • Class Profile fill-in-the-blank
    • ENGL 489 CLASS DISCUSSION BOARD
    • ENGL 489 PORTFOLIOS
    • ENGL 489 WRITER'S NOTEBOOK (ASSIGNMENTS)
    • ENGL 489 ICRN (ASSIGNMENTS)
    • ENGL 489 RETHINK/REVISE (ASSIGNMENTS)
    • ENGL 489 Interview with An Author (ASSIGNMENTS)
    • ENGL 489 MENTOR TEXT MEMOIR (ASSIGNMENTS)
    • ENGL 489 FINAL PROJECT (ASSIGNMENTS)
    • ENGL 489 Professionalization Presentations (ASSIGNMENTS)
  • Previously Taught Classes
    • POLICIES ENGL 511 SPECIAL TOPICS: YA LIT >
      • CLASS PROFILES YA LIT
      • LT UPDATES ENGL 511 YA LIT
      • Discussion Board YA Lit
      • SYLLABUS ENGL 511 YA LIT
      • ENGL 511 profile instructions
      • ENGL 511 YA LIT Mentor Text Memoir
      • ENGL 511 YA LIT Reader's Notes
      • ENGL 511 YA LIT pecha kucha final project
      • ENGL 511 Write Your Own YA
      • ENGL 511 FINAL PROJECT (individual)
    • ENGL406 RESEARCH IN WRITING STUDIES
    • ENGL344 YA LIT
    • ENGL101 policies
    • ENGL 226 policies >
      • ENGL 226 Writing Studies Timeline Project
    • ENGL 303 policies
    • ENGL 301
    • ENGL102
    • ENGL 202 BIZ Com
    • ENGL 227 INTRO TO CNF WORKSHOP
    • ENGL 298 Second Year Seminar: This Bridgewater Life
    • ENGL 493 THE PERSONAL ESSAY
    • ENGL 493 Seminar in Writing & Writing Studies: The History of First Year Composition
    • ENGL 511 Reading & Writing Memoir
    • ENGL 513 >
      • ENGL 513 MONDAY UPDATE
      • ENGL 513 DISCUSSION BOARD
      • CLASS PROFILE ENGL 513 COMP T&P
      • SYLLABUS ENGL 513 COMP T&P
      • PORTFOLIOS ENGL 513 COMP THEORY & PEDAGOGY
      • ASSIGNMENTS ENGL 513 COMP THEORY & PEDAGOGY: READING RESPONSES
      • ASSIGNMENTS ENGL 513 COMP THEORY & PEDAGOGY: Literacy History
      • ASSIGNMENTS ENGL 513 COMP THEORY & PEDAGOGY: Pedagogy Presentations
      • ASSIGNMENTS ENGL 513 COMP THEORY & PEDAGOGY: Reverse Annotated Bibliography
      • ASSIGNMENTS ENGL 513 COMP THEORY & PEDAGOGY: ETHNOGRAPHY/CASE STUDY
      • ASSIGNMENTS ENGL 513 COMP THEORY & PEDAGOGY: final project
    • DURFEE Engl101
  • BSU Homepage
  • Blog

Switched At Birth- Sarah Cummings

3/21/2014

0 Comments

 
Throughout the “Switched at Birth” podcast there are many different people being interviewed who are all involved with the dynamics of the story.  When the mother who did not know the secret, Mrs. MacDonald, was interviewed, she was very hurt because she did not raise the daughter she gave birth too.  The woman who knew the secret, Mrs. Miller, just seemed happy to have her biological daughter back and told Marti (her non-biological daughter) that she knew the whole time and just did not want to support her since she was not her biological child.  This leads the story to go from the listener believing that it will be a happy podcast because the daughters are with the right family, but the interviews change that whole perspective.  It showed how Mrs. Miller just wanted to tell the secret and get her biological daughter back.  Towards the end of the first act, I felt bad for Marti because I feel like she was the one left out by both families.  And Sue is taken in by the Millers and the MacDonalds feel like they have a duty to their daughter, even if it is not their biological one. 

            Also, I feel bad for Kay MacDonald because she was the last person to find out about the switch and she wanted a daughter so bad.  I feel like Mrs. Miller took something away from Mrs. MacDonald because the Millers had 5 daughters, while the MacDonald’s had one.  I really do not understand why Mrs. Miller would not tell the secret as soon as possible.  I understand she was sick and had good relations with the doctor but it is not fair to the MacDonalds.  At first, I felt like it was an honest mistake but she should have gone back to the doctor and fixed everything, even though her husband advised against it.  I am glad that near the end of Act 2, Mrs. Miller realizes her mistake and how she should have seen it earlier.  

0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Use this space to discuss the TAL program "Switched At Birth"

    Archives

    March 2014

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly
  • Home
  • ENGL 489 Advanced Portfolio
    • ENGL 489 SYLLABUS >
      • GUIDELINES FOR BEING PRESENT ONLINE
    • ENGL 489 AUTHOR BIOS >
      • Class Profile fill-in-the-blank
    • ENGL 489 CLASS DISCUSSION BOARD
    • ENGL 489 PORTFOLIOS
    • ENGL 489 WRITER'S NOTEBOOK (ASSIGNMENTS)
    • ENGL 489 ICRN (ASSIGNMENTS)
    • ENGL 489 RETHINK/REVISE (ASSIGNMENTS)
    • ENGL 489 Interview with An Author (ASSIGNMENTS)
    • ENGL 489 MENTOR TEXT MEMOIR (ASSIGNMENTS)
    • ENGL 489 FINAL PROJECT (ASSIGNMENTS)
    • ENGL 489 Professionalization Presentations (ASSIGNMENTS)
  • Previously Taught Classes
    • POLICIES ENGL 511 SPECIAL TOPICS: YA LIT >
      • CLASS PROFILES YA LIT
      • LT UPDATES ENGL 511 YA LIT
      • Discussion Board YA Lit
      • SYLLABUS ENGL 511 YA LIT
      • ENGL 511 profile instructions
      • ENGL 511 YA LIT Mentor Text Memoir
      • ENGL 511 YA LIT Reader's Notes
      • ENGL 511 YA LIT pecha kucha final project
      • ENGL 511 Write Your Own YA
      • ENGL 511 FINAL PROJECT (individual)
    • ENGL406 RESEARCH IN WRITING STUDIES
    • ENGL344 YA LIT
    • ENGL101 policies
    • ENGL 226 policies >
      • ENGL 226 Writing Studies Timeline Project
    • ENGL 303 policies
    • ENGL 301
    • ENGL102
    • ENGL 202 BIZ Com
    • ENGL 227 INTRO TO CNF WORKSHOP
    • ENGL 298 Second Year Seminar: This Bridgewater Life
    • ENGL 493 THE PERSONAL ESSAY
    • ENGL 493 Seminar in Writing & Writing Studies: The History of First Year Composition
    • ENGL 511 Reading & Writing Memoir
    • ENGL 513 >
      • ENGL 513 MONDAY UPDATE
      • ENGL 513 DISCUSSION BOARD
      • CLASS PROFILE ENGL 513 COMP T&P
      • SYLLABUS ENGL 513 COMP T&P
      • PORTFOLIOS ENGL 513 COMP THEORY & PEDAGOGY
      • ASSIGNMENTS ENGL 513 COMP THEORY & PEDAGOGY: READING RESPONSES
      • ASSIGNMENTS ENGL 513 COMP THEORY & PEDAGOGY: Literacy History
      • ASSIGNMENTS ENGL 513 COMP THEORY & PEDAGOGY: Pedagogy Presentations
      • ASSIGNMENTS ENGL 513 COMP THEORY & PEDAGOGY: Reverse Annotated Bibliography
      • ASSIGNMENTS ENGL 513 COMP THEORY & PEDAGOGY: ETHNOGRAPHY/CASE STUDY
      • ASSIGNMENTS ENGL 513 COMP THEORY & PEDAGOGY: final project
    • DURFEE Engl101
  • BSU Homepage
  • Blog